the porous city

Is there a general factor of intelligence?
Because of my personal beliefs (one could say biases) I have never accepted the idea that there's a meaningful underlying factor of intelligence g. Cosma Shalizi doesn't buy the existing evidence either.
. . . the case for g rests on a statistical technique, factor analysis, which works solely on correlations between tests. Factor analysis is handy for summarizing data, but can't tell us where the correlations came from; it always says that there is a general factor whenever there are only positive correlations. The appearance of g is a trivial reflection of that correlation structure. A clear example, known since 1916, shows that factor analysis can give the appearance of a general factor when there are actually many thousands of completely independent and equally strong causes at work. Heritability doesn't distinguish these alternatives either. Exploratory factor analysis being no good at discovering causal structure, it provides no support for the reality of g.

. . .

To paraphrase Hume:

When we run over libraries, persuaded of these principles, what havoc must we make? If we take in our hand any paper; of macroeconomics or correlational psychology, for instance; let us ask, Does it draw its causal inferences from observations with consistent methods? No. Does it draw its causal inferences from experiments, controlled or randomized? No. Commit it then to the recycling bin: for it can contain nothing but sophistry and illusion.


last modified: 19:17:23 12-Feb-2011
in categories:Science/Psychology, Other/Statistics

Comment

name*

email

homepage

No html.

what's the second letter of your name?

This is Lukas Bergstrom's weblog. You can also find me on Twitter and LinkedIn.

Tech
Product Management, Security, Social, barcamp, Energy, Net, Web, Development, Web analytics, OS, a11y, RSS, Hardware, Open, Data, Automobile, Javascript, Shopping, Android, MacOS, Visual, Storage, Crowdsourcing, s60, Mobile, Audio, Medical, Collaboration, Wearables, WRX, AI, PIM, Business

Other
Food & Drink, Friday, Law, San Francisco, Personal care, Boston, CrowdFlower, Transportation, Activism, Politik, Clothes, Toys, Travel, Games, Berlin, Geography, Minnesota, NYC, California, Video, History, Agriculture, Quizzes, Bicycling, Housing, Feminism, Sports, Podcasts, Surfing, L.A., Life hacks, Statistics

Music
Reviews, Mixes, Labels, Lyrics, Boston, Mailing lists, Business, Hip-hop, History, Shopping, Videos, L.A., Booking, Mp3s, House, Events, Musicians, Streams, Good tracks, Making

People
ADD, Stories, MOTAS, Friends, Health, Weblogs, Meditation, Languages, Buddhism, Gossip, Heroes, Family, Vocations, Working with, Life hacks, Exercise, Subcultures, Me, Enemies

Commerce
Management consulting, Taxes, Non-profit, Real Estate, Microfinance, Web, Investing, IP Law, Marketing and CRM, International Development, Insurance, Shopping, Personal services, Personal finance, Macroeconomics

Arts
Sculpture, Burning Man, Rhetoric, Comix, Desktop wallpaper bait, Events, iPad bait, Humor, Spoken Word, Outlets, Visual, Poetry, Movies, Animation, Literature

Design
Data visualization, Tools, Algorithmic, Type, Furniture, Architecture, User experience, Cool, Presentations, Web, Process, IA

Science
Cognition, Zoology, Statistics and Data, Environment, Psychology, Networks, Physics

Travel
Vagabond '08, Kingdom of Siam, Uganda, Kenya

Photos
Friends, Moblog, Photos I Wish I'd Taken

Philosophy
Mind

Internet classic

Mathematics

One Acre Fund

Subscribe to this site's rss feed